Earlier this year, the FTT concluded that a claim for a rent repayment order was a “joint remedy”, which meant that, where the rent had been paid under a joint tenancy, all the tenants had to be parties to the claim and claim the whole of the rent together. Giles wrote about it here. I understand other FTTs had followed that decision.
It was obviously a huge issue of considerable importance for the proper workings of rent repayment orders and so Giles volunteered to take on the case pro bono for the tenants. The FTT granted permission to appeal in light of the importance of the issue and, last week, Judge Cooke in the Upper Tribunal overturned the FTTs decision.
Brown and others v Semelo Shaw [2026] UKUT 448 (LC)
The facts are pretty simple and, I would suggest, common. The respondent owed a property which he let as an HMO. The letting was on a joint tenancy basis, with a rolling “churn” of occupiers (e.g. initial grant to A, B and C. Then A leaves and is replaced by D. And so on and so forth). The landlord needed, but did not have, an HMO licence and so three of the tenants sought rent repayment orders. The three had never been joint tenants under the same tenancy and each only sought an RRO for the rent which she had actually paid.
The FTT reasoned that the claim was flawed. As explained in the previous post, it drew attention to certain insolvency case-law which it considered showed that a claim for an RRO was a “joint claim” so that all persons entitled to the remedy had to be parties to the claim. That position was, so the FTT considered, reflected by CPR 19. As the three claimants had not been tenants under the same joint tenancy, their claim had to fail.
The Upper Tribunal rejected that logic, allowed the appeal and made three RROs.
It considered that that proper starting point was not insolvency case-law nor CPR 19. Rather, the starting point was the wording of the statute. The relevant parts of the Housing and Planning Act 2016 simply referred to a claim by “a tenant”. It was true that, at common law, “a tenant” under a joint tenancy meant all of the individuals together (which was, in essence, the point the FTT was making). But that was not an invariable rule. In particular, where Parliament (as here) had not defined “tenant”, then there was authority that the phrase “a tenant” could (in the context of a joint tenancy) mean either all the joint tenants acting collectively or any one of them acting alone (see Lloyd v Sadler [1978] QB 774). The question was what interpretation best gave effect to the intention of Parliament.
So, what did Parliament intend? There were several strands to consider. The RRO regime was intended to punish and deter bad landlords. It was hard to see how that purpose was furthered by a construction of the Act which prevented a single joint tenant from pursuing an RRO claim unless all her fellow joint tenants supported her as a party to the claim. Why should Parliament have wanted to create that additional hurdle simply because it was a joint tenancy? Had the landlord granted a sole tenancy of each room with a right to share the common parts, then this problem would not have arisen. That strange distinction tended to suggest that the FTTs decision must be wrong.
Moreover, none of the offences which gave rise to RRO claims had anything to do with whether the tenancy was joint or sole, which further suggested that the FTTs focus on the joint nature of the letting must be wrong.
Finally, if the FTT was right, how would RRO claims actually work? What happened where one tenant received housing benefit for some or all of the rent? Would the local authority have to be jointed? If HB paid all the rent, what purpose would be served by making the benefit-recipient tenant become a party when she could get no remedy? How would it work if the underlying offence had only been committed against one of the occupiers (e.g. the unlawful eviction offences)?
Given all those points, and applying Lloyd v Sadler, the correct position was that the reference to “a tenant” in the RRO legislation meant, in the context of a joint tenancy, any of the people who comprised the joint tenant under the tenancy.
The FTT had helpfully indicated what sums it would have awarded had it concluded it had jurisdiction to do so. The UT therefore directed those sums to be paid as RROs.
Comment
First, this is a return to what had been assumed to be the law before the previous FTT decision (see, e.g. Dowd v Martins [2022] UKUT 249 (LC), Moreira v Morrison [2023] UKUT 233 (LC), and Marcus v Kwok [2024] UKUT 219 (LC)).
Secondly, it’s obviously right.
Thirdly, and most importantly, the practical take away is that the claimant for an RRO – where they are merely one of a number of joint tenants – needs to ensure that they lead proper evidence about what they actually paid (i.e. their share of the rent). It is perfectly open to a landlord to say “prove it” on any claim. In particular where the tenants all pay one of their number as lead tenant, who then remits the payment to the landlord. But, assuming that evidence can be produced, then an RRO is available.
Here at NL we don’t usually write about cases we were involved in. I’ve decided to ignore that rule and write up this case even though I argued it for the tenants. The reason for that is because it gives me another chance to talk about Giles. His generosity in taking this case pro bono will, like so much of his work, continue to benefit people years, even decades down the line. We also won on what were essentially his arguments. I’m hugely grateful to his colleagues at Anthony Gold for agreeing to continue the case pro bono after his death and to the Upper Tribunal itself for the kind words about Giles at para.2.
Finally, it would be remiss of me not to also mention counsel for the landlord. James Andrews-Tipler and Hamish Fraser appeared pro bono for the landlord under a pilot scheme that Advocate (Bar Pro Bono Unit as was) are running. Their generosity in giving up their time and skill for free is something that we should all be grateful for. For good or ill, our system depends on adversarial argument and we all benefit when arguments are fully tested.
0 Comments