More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Filter by Categories
Allocation
ASB
Assured Shorthold tenancy
assured-tenancy
Benefits and care
Deposits
Disrepair
Homeless
Housing Conditions
Housing law - All
Introductory and Demoted tenancies
Leasehold and shared ownership
Licences and occupiers
Mortgage possession
Nuisance
Possession
Regulation and planning
right-to-buy
secure-tenancy
Succession
Trusts and Estoppel
Unlawful eviction and harassment

Feline deposits: a s-cat-tutory nuisance?

18/11/2026

Caerphilly County Borough Council v Williamson, R (on the application of) [2026] EWCA Civ 1402

Lord Justice Miles gets straight to the point: “This case is about cat fouling.”

Indeed it is, and I applaud the nerve of whichever member of the court saw fit to grant permission to appeal and thereby compel three of their esteemed colleagues to grapple with feline excrement.

Specifically, this is a case about whether your neighbour’s cats’ faeces, deposited in your garden (by the cats), can amount to a ‘statutory nuisance’ as defined in Part III of the Environmental Protection Act 1990.

Statutory provisions

Section 79(1) of the EPA 1990 lists various “matters” which constitute a “statutory nuisance”. The one most familiar to housing practitioners is at s79(1)(a): “any premises in such a state as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance”.

But two other “matters” are relevant in this case:

(e) any accumulation or deposit which is prejudicial to health or a nuisance;

(f) any animal kept in such a place or manner as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance;

Prejudicial to health is defined at s79(7) as meaning “injurious, or likely to cause injury, to health”.

Background

Mr Williamson, frustrated by the scatological proclivities of his neighbour’s cats[1], requested that Caerphilly County Borough Council investigate whether there was a statutory nuisance.

Caerphilly decided that there was not. It was satisfied that there was adequate provision for the cats to foul indoors. Mr Williamson’s neighbour was, in its view, conscientious about ensuring the cats had “the correct facility” for their … erm … business.

In respect of the legal framework, the council had concluded: “cats are not governed by the same roaming laws as dogs & livestock are. The common law principle is that there are no laws governing control, they have a ‘right to roam’.”

Taking all relevant factors into account, including that there were only three cats living in the property, the council came to the view that Mr Williamson’s neighbour was not “keeping animals in such a manner as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance.”

Judicial review claim

Mr Williamson sought judicial review. In January 2026, the High Court (His Honour Judge Jarman KC) found that Caerphilly had erred in its approach. In particular, the council had wrongly approached Mr Williamson’s complaint by considering only the manner in which the cats were kept and their right at common law to roam, rather than whether the fouling amounted to deposits prejudicial to health.

The court held that cat faeces were capable of being a “deposit” within the meaning of section 79(1)(e), and that deposits of this kind were capable of being prejudicial to health.

This was not a finding by the court that there was a statutory nuisance in Mr Williamson’s garden. Rather, Caerphilly was required to reconsider Mr Williamson’s complaint according to the correct legal principles.

Appeal

Caerphilly appealed, arguing that an accumulation or deposit under section 79(1)(e) of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 had to be the result of a purposeful or wilful act. (Presumably what it really meant by this was that it had to be a purposeful or wilful act of a human being.)

The Court of Appeal rejected this submission, taking the contrary view that, when one is considering whether there is a statutory nuisance, any questions about who was responsible for the nuisance are irrelevant at that initial stage. (The question of who is responsible becomes important later if there is a statutory nuisance – but this appeal was concerned only with the question of whether there was a statutory nuisance at all.)

Accordingly, the court held that the cat fouling was capable of being a deposit or accumulation, and hence could be a statutory nuisance.

Comment

What does all of this mean, in this particular case, and more broadly?

Caerphilly was required to make a fresh decision on whether a statutory nuisance existed in this particular case. In fact, by the time this matter was considered by the Court of Appeal, Caerphilly had already reconsidered and decided again that there was no statutory nuisance.

But if it is later found that there is a statutory nuisance, what then?

Section 80(1) of the EPA 1990 requires that, where a local authority is satisfied that a statutory nuisance exists, or is likely to occur or recur, it shall serve an abatement notice. From this it appears that Caerphilly would be required to serve an abatement notice, but on whom?

One commentator suggested that the abatement notice would have to be served on the complainant Mr Williamson, since if the person responsible for the nuisance cannot be found, the notice is to be served on the owner or occupier of the premises (see section 80(2)(c)). However, here the identity of the cats and their owner is known. I expect that Mr Williamson anticipates a different outcome.

[1] The names of the cats are not provided in the judgment – so much for open justice.

Share on Bluesky

Robin is a solicitor at Anthony Gold Solicitors in London. He also writes about housing law on LinkedIn and on the Anthony Gold website.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.