More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Filter by Categories
Assured Shorthold tenancy
Benefits and care
Housing Conditions
Housing law - All
Introductory and Demoted tenancies
Leasehold and shared ownership
Licences and occupiers
Mortgage possession
Regulation and planning
Trusts and Estoppel
Unlawful eviction and harassment

Local housing for local people


Margaret Hodge has decided that this is a good time to say that too much Council housing is going to economic migrants at the expense of local residents. Allocation policies should be rethought to reward ‘length of residence, citizenship and national insurance contributions’.

Carefully, the Industry Minister has managed to conflate the ‘coming over here taking our housing’ and the ‘un/deserving poor’ knee jerk reactions. Housing for the hardworking poor British, cries the Barking MP. Co-incidentally Barking and Dagenham have made the BNP the second largest party on the local Council.Margart Hodge

The trouble is that Hodge has put her finger on a genuine problem, but, whether through ignorance or calculation, has decided to perpetuate some unpleasant myths about it.

There is a huge shortage of Council housing and people who have lived in an area all or much of their lives are faced with their children finding it impossible to get a affordable place of their own or get a transfer to an adequately sized property. This most certainly breeds anger and resentment when it appears that others are simply walking into homes. I hear it every day and it is, without a doubt, a strongly felt view.

But where Hodge’s soundbites are dangerous is in echoing these resentments rather than a serious look at allocations policy and where the problems actually arise.

Hodge is quoted as saying:

“In exercising that choice as an economic migrant, should they then presume to have automatic access immediately to public social housing?”

But who are these ‘economic migrants’ snaffling Council housing? Who is getting immediate automatic access to housing? Let us see.

People who can’t access Council housing assistance at all include:

  • Asylum seekers
  • Anyone on a work, student, business or marital visa with a ‘no recourse to public funds’ limitation (just about all of them), infact pretty much anyone subject to immigration control.
  • ‘Old’ EU citizens who are not workers or workseekers (so anyone unemployed for roughly over 6 months)
  • ‘New’ A8 EU citizens, if they are not working (for any reason) at any time in the first twelve months of stay, or are not registered on the WRS [Corrected 21/5]. After twelve months continuous work, same as ‘old’ EU.
  • ‘Even Newer’ A2 EU citizens, as with A8.

Who does that leave? Who are these swarms nicking ‘our’ housing? It may well be that what people are seeing is housing of asylum seekers (not by the Council) and some housing by social services of homeless with children who have been refused the housing duty. Sometimes Council stock is used, generally that which can’t be let via the usual route. But the basic point remains true. An ‘economic migrant’ who has pretty much anything less than indefinite leave to remain, or isn’t EU and employed, is going to have severe difficulty getting Council housing.

[Edit 21/5/07 – of course, if Hodge wants to limit EU workers access to, in effect, welfare rights, there is going to be an almighty battle with the EU as well.]

And then the allocation policies are required to give priority to the homeless or those with health or medical needs, overcrowding etc., over measuring time of residence in the area or time on the waiting list. Anyone without those range of needs will be on a lower band and wait for a very long time regardless.

This indicates the real problem. The utter lack of housing stock. No revision of the allocation policy is going to make a significant difference to the pent up anger unless accompanied by a large scale increase in available stock (including repairing currently unusable housing). Of course the Tories started the problem with the double whammy of right to buy and stopping Councils using rent revenue to build more stock. But Labour have presided over the continuation of this policy and are only now showing signs of waking up to affordable housing as a major issue.

Hodge strikes me as displaying typical new Labour instincts in wanting to change allocation policy from being based on ‘need’ to the basis of being ‘deserving’. To then blame ‘economic migrants’ for the shortage of housing stock in pressured areas strikes me as downright irresponsible. Recognising your constituent’s concerns is one thing, parroting them without actually looking into the issue is another. One might even consider it to be a cynical gesture.

Giles Peaker is a solicitor and partner in the Housing and Public Law team at Anthony Gold Solicitors in South London. You can find him on Linkedin and on Twitter. Known as NL round these parts.


  1. the chief

    Spot on. I’ve previously worked with asylum seekers and in homelessness and both are groups (not mutually exclusive, of course) of people who are often seen as jumping the queue for Council houses. This kind of over simplification completely fails to address what, as you point out, is a genuine problem. The answer? More housing stock would certainly be a good starting point.

  2. Belle de Jure

    An excellent post! Not only do we need more housing stock, but doing something about those awful estates to make them nice places to live in would also be good.

  3. Julie Smith

    here here!

    it is not fair.

    I have 7 year old triplets and am still stuck in a 2 bed flat was told would have house in 5 years tops. we both work v hard and recieve NO benefits but get NO credit for it.



  1. Belle de Jure - BabyBarista Binary Law Charon QC Geeklawyer Lawyer 2 B Legal Scribbbles Nearly Legal
  2. Belle de Jure - MySpace Blog - Nearly Legal's excellent post on Margaret Hodge and the government's attitude toward social housing,as well as my own rant on…
  3. prisonlawinsideout: Margaret Hodge MP goes Barking mad and joins the BNP - [...] would appear that Margaret Hodge MP, Labour for Barking, has gone barking mad with racist outpourings more in keeping…
  4. Head of Legal: EU citizens, social housing and Margaret Hodge - [...] Nearly Legal - an excellent blawg with particular strength in housing law - wrote interestingly the other day about…
  5. EU citizens and social housing at Nearly Legal - [...] is gained under Art 16 (5 years residence), the qualifications to entitlement I set out in the ‘Hodge’ post…
  6. The Hodge Affair « Free Movement - [...] debate on housing allocation and immigration, covered elsewhere in the legal blogging world by Nearly Legal and Head of…
  7. Hodge woz wrong - official | Nearly Legal - [...] may have taken nearly a year after Margaret Hodge’s ‘they come over here taking our housing’ outburst, but it…
  8. Social Housing Survey » Martin George - [...] major survey into social housing allocation has found, contrary to Margaret Hodge’s controversial outburst last year, that the system…

Leave a Reply (We can't offer advice on individual issues)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.