More results...

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Filter by Categories
Assured Shorthold tenancy
Benefits and care
Housing Conditions
Housing law - All
Introductory and Demoted tenancies
Leasehold and shared ownership
Licences and occupiers
Mortgage possession
Regulation and planning
Trusts and Estoppel
Unlawful eviction and harassment

A sign of things to come?

By J

In the December edition of Legal Action, I noticed a decision from November 2012 (yes, 2012), called Miah v McGrogan [2012] EWCA Civ 1685 (Casetrack only).

Mr Miah seems to have been the landlord of a house which had been let to a number of students. They complained about the condition of the property and, although some remedial work was done, it was accepted that works remained outstanding (that might be too generous – Sullivan LJ notes that the Recorder “…conclude[d] not merely that the property was not in a properly habitable state at the start of the tenancy, but it also continued to be in a state that was not habitable up until April 2010…”.

Anyway, the students didn’t pay the last installment of rent, so Mr Miah sued.

The Recorder agreed that the property was in disrepair and that the tenants had been entitled to withhold the rent in response. In effect, there was a disrepair counter-claim which operated as an equitable set-off to the rent arrears claim.

The difficulty, said Mr Miah, was that no such counter-claim or set-off had ever been pleaded. That, said Sullivan LJ was “…little more than a somewhat unattractive pleading point.” The landlord was professionally represented. He knew what the case against him was. The students were all acting in person. There was nothing objectionable to the Recorder dealing with the case on the facts as she found them to be and not regarding herself as bring rigidly limited to the pleadings. Permission to appeal refused.



J is a barrister. He considers housing law to be the single greatest kind of law known to humankind and finds it very odd that so few people share this view.


Leave a Reply (We can't offer advice on individual issues)

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.