Monthly Archive for November, 2007

Constructive Trust and Proprietary Estoppel again

In James v Thomas [2007] EWCA Civ 1212, the Court of Appeal fine-tuned some points on constructive trust and proprietary estoppel, with reference to shares in property. To note from Sir John Chadwick’s main judgment:

A constructive trust can arise some years after the purchase of the property by the sole title holder alone. There is no requirement for the claimed beneficial interest to arise at the time of purchase. However, in this situation, without an express post-acquisition agreement, the Court will be slow to to infer an agreement from conduct alone.

Contribution to mortgage capital repayment per se is not necessarily enough to infer agreement to a beneficial … Read the full post

Badness in courts, of courts and of law lecturers

A quick outline of a busy news day…

What Price JusticeThe Court of Appeal says that (some) provisions of the Legal Services Commission’s Unified Contract are unlawful, specifically the most sweeping of the unilateral amendment clauses. The judgment is pretty devastating, finding for the Law Society on all points of its appeal of the earlier Judicial Review finding and against the LSC on their appeal. As a sample:

The power to amend (in this contract) is better characterised as a power to rewrite the contract.

Permission for the LSC to appeal refused, costs against the LSC. The judgment is here [pdf] and the Law Society’s comment here. What this will mean … Read the full post

Extending security by tenancy agreement?

[Edit, time slightly later on. In the comments to her post Tessa suggests that the case discussed below was not a judgment at all but merely adjourned from the undefended list for a hearing of the issues. So none of what follows is of much significance.]

A very interesting post over on Landlord Law by Tessa Shepperson.

Apparently a Deputy District Judge of her acquaintance, faced with a Notice to Quit served on a (ex) secure tenant who had moved out of the rented property, discovered that the Council tenancy agreement specified that the

tenant could only be evicted after service of a notice of possession as provided under the

Read the full post

S.85 Application Randomness

We’ve been doing quite a few s.85 revival of tenancy applications recently, mostly successful. Where arrears have been paid off, our usual line is that … Read the full post

Legal Aid. Could be clearer. Will be smaller.

The judgment in Minister for Legal Aid v Main, R (on the application of) [2007] EWCA Civ 1147 might be of limited general applicability, concerning as it does the provision of ‘special case’ legal aid funding for inquests, but one passage in the judgment caught my eye:

The relevant statutory provisions and the non-statutory material are somewhat complex. We were shown extracts from a “Legal Services Commission Manual”, which purports to explain the applicable directions and guidance. However, it confuses matters by mixing material from various sources without precise attribution. We were told that it has now been replaced by a clearer document. Meanwhile, we are grateful to Miss Nathalie

Read the full post

Oh what a tangled web…

[Edit. This was originally posted on Friday evening 16/11/07. Not that I'm getting all conspiratorial but it disappeared in the great site downtime and server change... There was also originally an image, which has vanished from the server and apparently was deleted (by me) on my home machine. So, albeit imageless, I defy the internet gods and post this again]

While Musharraf tries to overcome the rule of law by imprisoning all the lawyers and the Lord Chief Justice pleads, probably in vain, for a genuine discussion of prison policy, Nearly Legal’s scarce free moments today have been largely consumed by the ramifications of the posturing of a small … Read the full post

Rumours of my demise…

… were entirely due to a technical hitch. Admittedly a walloping great big technical hitch which lasted 3 days and was only resolved by the site being moved a new server and the Domain Name Server records being updated. But as of 11.30 pm on Monday, the site is working again. What time you get to see it live once more depends on how slowly the new DNS information spreads around t’internet.

Still, the sense of panic, bewilderment and deprivation the 3 day outage instilled has set me wondering about little things like dependency, addiction and the whole quality of life issue…

By the way, if anyone emailed me between … Read the full post



row of sheds footer image
3 pages